for writers and readers….

What makes a good review? What makes a good reviewer?

rosie amber 1Reviewers have probably never been so important. They have always been the life blood of an author’s career, but they are no longer the sole preserve of the ‘professional’, the paid contributor to a newspapers literary pages. A new kind of democracy has grown up with the internet where the amateur (aka the reader) can play an important role whether on Amazon’s pages or on their own blog

I read reviews if I’m going to buy a new vacuum cleaner or a new book from an author I haven’t read before. I read the best reviews and the worst and very often they help me to make up my mind. But sometimes it will say more about the person who wrote it than it does about the product under focus. I don’t like gush. It’s easy to say a book or a cleaner is awesomely wonderful, and much harder to give a reason why it deserves such positive comments.

Words can also wound and sometimes it seems that the reviewer forgets that there is a real person behind the novel or work of art. (Corporations, however, are fair game.)

I also read reviews of my own work. Of course, I do. Every. single. word. I don’t really believe writers or artists or musicians who say they don’t – well, I don’t suppose Mick Jagger bothers much anymore, but most people who create something want to know how others respond to it. It may hurt, but the only review worth having is an honest one.

Today I’m handing my blog over to Rosie Amber, a blogger and a prolific reviewer who has created an international reviewing team.

Thank you for inviting me to your blog today Bridget for a chat about book reviewing.

I’m Rosie Amber and I run a book reviewing blog at

You can also find me on Twitter @rosieamber1

Why as a reader I think reviews are important

In today’s world the book market is reaching saturation point. Self-publishing and e-book opportunities have opened the doors to publishing which were once held closed by publishing houses. More and more people are buying books online where they look at the book cover, the book description and they check out other reader’s reviews.

I love reading and want to share the books I love with others, so what better way than by writing a review and posting it on various online platforms and book buying sites.

As a reviewer, I post reviews about nearly all the books I read as long as I can rate them 3* or above. Below this I won’t review, I feel a “no review” says as much as a 1 or 2*. If I’ve been asked to review the book for an author and it will be below 2*, I’ll contact the author with an appraisal of their book, with my thoughts on how it could be improved.

 rosie gardening

What makes a good review?

I write short reviews. I’ll explain the book genre up front, then if it’s not one a reader likes, they can move on. I’ll usually talk quickly about the main characters and where or when the book is set. I’ll then go on to give a bit of information about the storyline, so that readers can decide themselves if the book sounds enticing. I’ll finish with a summary of what I liked about the book and if necessary what didn’t work for me. If the book needed another run through editing I will mention that and it will reflect in my rating. It’s so important in this competitive market for writers to put out their VERY best piece of work and not rush to publish.

Running a review blog

A year ago I filled my blog with all my own reviews, but my request list was getting long and I was being asked to review genres which I didn’t enjoy. So I created a book review team. Members join on a voluntary basis and review books around their own lives. There is no minimum or maximum number of books to read as long as they read and review a book in a month. We post reviews on,, Goodreads, reviewer’s blogs and I get a copy of each review which goes out on my own blog.

It is set up so that authors provide several copies of their work and we give them multiple reviews of the book all from one place.

It is complex, I’m fielding book review enquiries from authors, managing the review requests from the team, making sure they review within the one month and dealing with any of their queries, sending out notification to the author when the reviews comes in and drafting up my copy of each review for my blog. On top of that I have my own review request list which is currently around 50 books. I try to read a book in no longer than 2 days. This is a hobby, I have to work it around family life and part time employment. All the reviewing is free with no monetary values exchanged. This is important with the current Amazon clamp down on paid reviews and fake reviews breaching their rules.

Approaching us for a review

The best type of author wanting a review is one that has found my blog, spent a good time checking out the type of books we read, the style of reviews we write and actually getting involved with some of the posts via comments and sharing on social media. I hang out on Twitter a great deal.

Then when they have got a good feel for us I’m happy for them to make contact via the contact forms. There is a good set of instructions about the RIGHT way to go about it.

It’s very obvious if a new author finds my blog, “Follows” by joining and then fills in the book request form. I get all the e-mails, the one which says “You have a new follower” and when it’s followed by a book review request I KNOW the author has spent little time checking me out.

Then when they send a copy and paste review request or they call me Amber or no name at all, I get miffed. Most authors understand I’m busy reading and living my life and I will get to their book, some are a little impatient. DON’T OFFEND A REVIEWER BEFORE THEY’VE READ YOUR BOOK!

All I ask is that authors remember the team and I are human, we do this because we like reading, we won’t like every book we read but we won’t be rude or leave a 1* and no reason why. We spend several hours reading your book and thinking about a fair review all for free and in our own time so that you might benefit from others who will buy your book.

Thank you Rosie – your advice not to offend a reviewer before they’ve actually read your book is a good reminder that we are all human. 

21 comments on “What makes a good review? What makes a good reviewer?

  1. Rosie Amber
    July 13, 2015

    Reblogged this on Rosie Amber and commented:
    Last week Bridget Whelan invited me to join her for a chat about book reviewing.

    • bridget whelan
      July 13, 2015

      Thank you for being such an interesting and informative guest Rosie

  2. judithbarrow1
    July 13, 2015

    Reblogged this on Barrow Blogs: and commented:
    Are you an author? Want a review? Then read this. Carefully! Are you a reader? Don’t know how to find a book in the genre you enjoy? Then check out Rosie’s blog – the reviews will point you in the right direction:

    • bridget whelan
      July 13, 2015

      Thanks for reblogging Judith – it’s good for writers to get an insight in the reviewer’s experience

  3. Terry Tyler
    July 13, 2015

    As a member of Rosie’s review team who previously had her books reviewed by it, and before it existed by Rosie herself, I would like to say three cheers to Rosie Amber! As a reader, I love the different styles of reviewing by my other team members; my favourites have begun to emerge and I know that if certain reviewers say that a book is excellent it will probably be right up my street too – ‘click buy!’ As a writer – well, Rosie’s book blog is one of the best things that’s happened to my books, and I’ve always seen sales after a great review. As a reviewer, one of the things I like about the team is that we don’t gush gush, or pull a book apart without stating a case for the good parts too. They’re honest, and orientated towards the reader, as reviews should be.

    Gracias, Bridget and Rosie 🙂

    • bridget whelan
      July 13, 2015

      Full disclosure – Terry has just reviewed Back to Creative Writing School but this guest post was posted before the review was published. I approached Rosie in the first place because her review site is a really good read: no hatchet jobs but also no promotional puffs where everything the author attempts is just too awesome for words. Thoughtful, honest reviews are the only ones worth having….

      • Terry Tyler
        July 14, 2015

        I’m glad that’s how you see the review team, Bridget, and couldn’t agree more 🙂

  4. Helen Pollard
    July 13, 2015

    I’m so pleased I found Rosie’s book blog. As a reader, I enjoy it because Rosie and her team are very wide-ranging in the genres of book they review which keeps it interesting. And as a writer, it’s great that your book may go out to more than one reviewer and good to know that whilst being objective, they will not be scathing or unkind!

  5. junekearns
    July 13, 2015

    Another good guide, Rosie. I like the way you break the review down into a few sections. That’s really helpful.

  6. alisonewilliams
    July 13, 2015

    Reblogged this on Alison Williams Writing and commented:
    A great interview with Rosie Amber that’s a must read for anyone who wants a review for their book.

  7. JB Johnston
    July 13, 2015

    Excellent piece! Rosie is a great reviewer and I am proud to have her as one of my tour hosts. Always very professional and fair. x

  8. Elle Klass
    July 13, 2015

    Reviews are extremely important. As an author a well written review gives me insight into my book. Rosie and her team write excellent honest reviews. Their feedback has assisted me possibly more than they know. As a reader I pay attention to the reviews and note various authors whose books I want to check out.

    • bridget whelan
      July 13, 2015

      I agree that a good review can give the writer valuable feedback (feedback that you may wish to have had earlier, of course….)

  9. claireannette1
    July 13, 2015

    Thanks for posting this interview. I follow Rosie’s blog and it is interesting to read her thoughts of reviewing.

    • bridget whelan
      July 13, 2015

      Really interesting to hear from the other side of the fence….

  10. jenanita01
    July 14, 2015

    good reviewers are worth their weight in gold, and Rosie’s blog is one of the best!

  11. Susan Scott
    July 14, 2015

    Thank you so much – a very valuable post indeed! Rosie is a super star with her heart in the right place which makes her and her team stand shoulders above many reviewers.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


This entry was posted on July 6, 2015 by in Guest Post and tagged , , , .


%d bloggers like this: